Preacher's Cave
A collapsed cave at the northern tip of Eleuthera where shipwrecked English Puritans sheltered and held services in 1648.
Updated 1 September 2026
In 1648 a party of English Puritans sailing from Bermuda to found a colony wrecked on the Devil's Backbone reef off northern Eleuthera and came ashore near this cave, which they used as shelter and as a meeting house, cutting a pulpit-like block from the rock. The Eleutheran Adventurers gave the island its name. The cave is a large collapsed chamber with light coming through the roof, and excavation has found both colonial and earlier Lucayan burials in the floor.
The main sights
- The chamber - a large collapsed cave with daylight through the fallen roof.
- The rock pulpit - the cut block the settlers are said to have used for services.
- The excavated floor - burials from both the settler period and earlier Lucayan use.
- The setting - low coppice and a beach a short walk north.
When to go
November to April is the dry season and the most comfortable. The cave is open ground and needs no arrangement. Mornings give the best light through the roof opening.
What to expect
There is limited interpretation on site and the story is told mostly by guides and by a sign. The track in from the highway is rough. The floor is uneven and there is no lighting.
Nearby
The northern Eleuthera beaches are close, and Gregory Town is south along the island.
What to pack for Preacher's Cave
Chosen from what this place is for. Tap a kit for the full checklist.
- Reef-safe sunscreen - High SPF that will not bleach the coral you are swimming over. Find on Amazon
- Head torch + spare batteries - Hands-free light is essential; caves are truly dark. Find on Amazon
- Quick-dry towel - A microfibre towel packs small and dries in minutes. Find on Amazon
- Grippy closed shoes - Cave floors are wet, muddy and slick with formations. Find on Amazon
Some links on this page are Amazon affiliate links - if you buy through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
All packing kitsPlan your trip
Where to start if Preacher's Cave is going on the list.
Booking links on this page are affiliate links - if you book through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes what we write about a place.
Opening times, ticket prices and seasonal closures change - check the official source before you go: official site.





